Who's Fooling Whom?
Touchstone
is a professional Fool, a court jester. Like Feste in Twelfth
Night, he is “an allowed fool” – someone permitted to speak
unpleasant truths, as long as it's done in an entertaining way. As
Frederick grows more and more insecure about his status as Duke, he
becomes less and less willing to hear witty criticisms of his rule
and of his followers. One courtier describes Touchstone to Frederick
as “the roynish [mangy or annoying] clown,
at whom so oft your Grace
was wont to laugh”:
the Fool has clearly fallen out of favor. Celia is worried that he'll
be whipped for overstepping the new bounds of acceptable jesting.
Touchstone responds to her warning with the rueful observation, “The
more pity, that fools may not speak wisely what wise men do
foolishly.” The Forest of Arden, with all its inconveniences (which
Touchstone will eagerly catalog), is still more welcoming than
Frederick's court, so Touchstone accompanies Rosalind and Celia in
exile.
Jaques,
impressed by Touchstone's cynical wit and unaware of the practical
limits that professional jesters often face, naively thinks that
Fools enjoy utter liberty in speaking their minds. Although he
announces himself “ambitious for a motley coat,” the jester's
uniform, he helps Touchstone find new employment in the service of
Duke Senior. Touchstone's audition piece is a tour de force critique
of notions of honor (his first topic with Rosalind and Celia, as
well): his seven degrees of the lie map out how much one can take
until one is socially obligated to fight a duel for honor's sake –
and even then how one might avoid the duel by enlisting the power of
If.
Fool,
however, is also an insult. A “natural” fool suffers from a lack
of wit – meaning intelligence. Rosalind and Celia teasingly refer
to Touchstone as a “natural”; Frederick repeatedly tells his
daughter that she is a fool for not being suspicious of Rosalind.
Jaques and Orlando exchange barbs by indirectly calling each other
fool; before that, Jaques is able to "call fools into a circle" with his new lyrics for one of Amiens' songs. Even Touchstone dismisses William, his rival for Audrey, as the
wrong kind of fool: when William compliments himself for having a
“pretty wit,” Touchstone reminds him that “The fool doth think
he is wise, but the wise man knows himself to be a fool.” The idea
of a fool having “little wit,” however, contributes to the
element of surprise in the professional Fool's critiques and also
softens the blow . . . somewhat.
Flatwater Free Shakespeare's As You Like It wraps up its summer tour this weekend! Thursday at Densmore Park, 6761 S. 14th. Friday at Lincoln Community Foundation Garden, near 14th and N. Saturday and Sunday at The Swan Theatre at Wyuka Stables, 3600 "O" Street. Showtime 7 p.
Photo: Megan Higgins as Rosalind, Emma Gruhl as Celia, and Tom Crew as Touchstone in Flatwater Shakespeare's As You Like It. Photo Credit: Mark Lee.